Follow the Harvard Press on FacebookFollow us on Facebook!  and TwitterFollow us on Twitter!

Tuesday, May 22, 2012  ·  Contact Us Register  ·  Subscribe/Renew  ·  Login
 
Reviews
Book Review: A cautionary tale

Nathaniel Philbrick’s wonderful new book, Mayflower, is a great pre-Thanksgiving read, serving up generous helpings of Pilgrim lore garnished with historically accurate and convincing detail.

Like many of you, I grew up nourished by the canonical images of stalwart Pilgrims—little folk in funny hats and silver shoe buckles—introducing a docile band of Native Americans to the civilizing virtues of friendship, piety, and turkey with gravy.

Philbrick makes Plymouth come alive—a small community built, to some extent, on shared values and mutual dependence. Not everyone agreed on every issue, but all recognized the importance of working together to protect themselves against a host of harsh adversities—from interlopers intent on changing a way of life, to bitter winters, to hostile Indians. I found myself thinking that, except for the Indian threat, Philbrick could be writing about Harvard.

In the winter of 1623, news reached Plymouth that their staunch ally, Massasoit, was at death’s door. Governor Bradford immediately dispatched an emissary to the powerful chief whose untimely demise could upset a very tenuous balance of power. Edward Winslow, a printer by trade, was sent on the mission, accompanied by an Indian named Hobbamock, a translator of dubious motives and political alignments.

Halfway through the 40-mile trip, Winslow received news that Massasoit had died. Hobbamock insisted that they return to Plymouth at once. Winslow thought it more prudent to keep going and, if nothing else, to attempt to shore up relations with Massasoit’s successor. When further news arrived that Massasoit was still alive, Winslow resolved to press on, arriving at the chief’s wigwam after dark.

Winslow fed Massasoit some fruit preserves, “administered on the tip of a knife,” and the old chief seemed to get better. By the next day, Massasoit was requesting that Winslow go out and shoot a duck and make up a tasty stew. Winslow did as he was asked, and the resulting greasy concoction caused the Chief to become so violently ill that he almost died again. He did recover, however, and is said to have remarked, “Now that I see the English are my friends and love me, I will never forget this kindness they have showed me.”

As a token of his gratitude, Massasoit passed along the information that Indians planned to attack the village of Wessagussett, north of Plymouth, and then carry the battle to Plymouth itself. It was terrifying to realize, as Winslow put it, that they were “at the pit’s brim, and yet feared nor knew not that we were in danger.” Armed with knowledge of the attack and with Massasoit’s backing, the Pilgrims averted disaster and went on to enjoy many more Thanksgivings.

It’s a ripping good tale that hits surprisingly close to home. Because the pilgrims cultivated alliances based on trust and mutual respect, they had access to reliable information. Because they kept their ear to the ground, they were alert to changes that might affect their lives. Because they acted with good will, they reaped the rewards of being dependable neighbors and kept their fragile community intact and thriving.

Good job Mr. Philbrick! Showing our Pilgrim forebears in human dimension—valuable. Making history relevant—worth even more. Illuminating the crucial need for timely, accurate, and reliable access to real news—priceless.

Filed under: Reviews
Comments
 
 
Post Comment
 

Name (required)

Email (required)

Website

CAPTCHA image
Enter the code shown above:


The archives below, available to logged-in paid subscribers, contain older reviews.

Numbers in parentheses indicate count of reviews in the given month.

May 2012 (2)     April 2012 (2)     March 2012 (2)     February 2012 (2)     
January 2012 (2)     December 2011 (3)     November 2011 (3)     October 2011 (1)     
September 2011 (2)     August 2011 (2)     July 2011 (2)     June 2011 (4)     
May 2011 (3)     April 2011 (3)     March 2011 (2)     February 2011 (4)     
January 2011 (4)     December 2010 (3)     November 2010 (4)     October 2010 (3)     
September 2010 (3)     August 2010 (2)     July 2010 (1)     June 2010 (3)     
May 2010 (1)     April 2010 (4)     March 2010 (3)     February 2010 (3)     
January 2010 (3)     December 2009 (4)     November 2009 (3)     October 2009 (3)     
September 2009 (4)     August 2009 (2)     July 2009 (2)     June 2009 (2)     
May 2009 (6)     April 2009 (1)     March 2009 (3)     February 2009 (4)     
January 2009 (1)     December 2008 (2)     November 2008 (3)     October 2008 (4)     
September 2008 (4)     August 2008 (4)     July 2008 (2)     June 2008 (3)     
May 2008 (3)     April 2008 (3)     March 2008 (3)     February 2008 (5)     
January 2008 (3)     December 2007 (2)     November 2007 (5)     October 2007 (5)     
September 2007 (5)     August 2007 (4)     July 2007 (1)     June 2007 (5)     
May 2007 (5)     April 2007 (5)     March 2007 (5)     February 2007 (7)     
January 2007 (5)     December 2006 (7)     November 2006 (4)     

CLICK AN AD!
Dinner at Deadline
Mounsey Mulch
Turbo Lube
Whole Earth
Inspired Design
Merrill Excavating
Marcus Lewis Day Camp
Bull Run Restaurant
Colonial Spirits
3Rivers Arts
Copyright 2006–2012 by The Harvard Press LLC  ·  PO Box 284  ·  Harvard, Massachusetts 01451  ·  Phone 978.456.3700  ·  Fax 978.274.5605  ·  Terms Of Use  ·  Privacy Statement  ·  Site Credit